Every newsletter operator thinks they have an engagement problem.
The truth?
Most of you don’t have an engagement problem.
You have a measurement problem.
Because the open rates and click rates your ESP reports aren’t telling you what you think they are.
And it all comes down to one simple truth we discovered (again) this week:
**👉 If an open or click happens within the first 2 minutes of delivery…
it’s probably not a human.**
Not a reader.
Not a fan.
Not someone leaning in and consuming your content.
Just a bot.
A link scanner.
A security system.
A false positive tricking you into thinking your list is healthier than it is.
We saw this firsthand in a recent analysis: entire segments showing 100% click-through rates… from GI domains, Microsoft security bots, and automated scanners hitting every link the moment the email lands.
Meanwhile, actual humans weren’t engaging at all — but you’d never know it if you trusted the standard ESP dashboards.
🚨 The Engagement Metrics You Trust Are Becoming Useless
Look at what ESPs quietly introduced in the past 6 months:
“Human Opens and Human Clicks” (Customer.io)
“Verified Clicks” (Beehiiv)
“Human Openers” logic baked into multiple platforms
Bot filtering and link scanning identification features
Why?
Because the industry is finally admitting what we’ve been seeing across millions of sends:
Most clicks are not human clicks.
Most opens are not human opens.
And if you’re optimizing your list, your segments, or your entire business around those numbers… you’re steering the ship using fake data.
🔥 The 2-Minute Rule: The New Standard for Real Engagement
Here’s how we measure true engagement across the Audience Bridge network — and how every serious operator should approach it:
The Rule:
If a subscriber opens OR clicks within 2 minutes of delivery, it does NOT count as human engagement.
Why?
Because real people:
Don’t receive an email and instantly click 5 links
Aren’t subscribed under a dozen GI domains
Don’t behave like automated antivirus software
Don’t generate clicks without corresponding opens
Don’t click within 1–10 seconds of delivery
But bots do.
Microsoft does.
Security systems do.
We saw segments where clickers exceeded openers — mathematically impossible for humans, but perfectly normal for automated systems that fire link scans without loading tracking pixels.
💡 What Happens When You Filter Out All Non-Human Engagement?
This is where things get interesting.
When you apply the 2-minute rule and remove bot-driven signals, operators almost always see the same pattern:
1. Your list is less engaged than you think
But it’s more honest — and that honesty saves you from damaging your sender reputation.
2. Your list size is inflated by ghost engagement
Clickers who never clicked.
Openers who never opened.
This leads to over-sending, which destroys Gmail reputation (the biggest issue we saw this week).
3. Your best subscribers finally become visible
Once you strip the noise, your real loyal readers show up.
These are the people you build around.
4. Your deliverability improves — fast
When you stop rewarding bot-heavy segments, your domain reputation recovers dramatically faster across Gmail, Yahoo, and Outlook.
📉 Why Engagement Declines Even When “Metrics” Look Strong
This is the scary part.
A bot can:
Open every email
Click every link
Inflate your average
Trigger bad logic in your sending strategy
…but it won’t ever buy anything.
It won’t ever share your newsletter.
It won’t ever become a real fan.
Worse?
Sending to these “auto-engagers” kills your deliverability, especially at Gmail — which was the biggest pain point in our internal review this week.
You end up sending more email…
To the wrong people…
Which gets you inboxed less often…
Which leads to real subscribers seeing your newsletter less…
Which drops your revenue…
And people wonder why their growth “mysteriously” plateaus.
Here’s where everything is heading:
By the end of 2026, every serious publisher will measure human-only engagement.
Everyone else will be flying blind.
Platforms are moving this direction.
Advertisers are demanding it.
ISPs require it.
And if you want:
Better inbox placement
More engaged readers
Higher RPMs
Better performance for your sponsors
Faster list growth
…you need to know who your actual readers are.
Not bots.
Not scanners.
Not fake clickers.
Humans.
The email ecosystem is shifting fast.
If you’re still measuring opens and clicks the old way, you’re not just behind — you’re at risk.
The 2-Minute Rule is simple.
But it’s the beginning of a much larger shift toward real signal data, smarter segmenting, and ultimately…
a healthier, more profitable newsletter business.
If you want help identifying real engagement inside your list — or cleaning up the fake engagement that’s currently hurting you — just reply to this email.
We’ve built systems at Audience Bridge to measure this across millions of subscribers, and the results have been transformative.
Only humans should reply,
Chris Miquel
If Audience Bridge Insights has helped you improve your email operation, would you share what you've learned?
Takes 2 minutes, helps other operators discover us.
Recent subscriber testimonial: "The breakdown on Gmail's new sender requirements saved us from a major deliverability crisis. Implemented in 24 hours." - Dan K., Finance Newsletter
BEFORE YOU GO
How did you like today's newsletter?
Better Inbox Placement Starts Here
If your emails aren’t landing in the inbox, they’re not doing their job. I’ve seen too many brands struggle with deliverability issues without knowing why.
The truth is, a few key optimizations can make all the difference in getting your emails seen, opened, and clicked.
